| Sir Richard Cholmondely (Lieutenant of the Tower) | Timothy Cha |
| Colonel Fairfax (Under sentence of death) | Sam Perwin |
| Sergeant Meryll (Of the Yeomen of the Guard) | Scott Asher |
| Leonard Meryll (His Son) | Morgan Wolbe |
| Jack Point (A Strolling Jester) | Oussama Zahr |
| Wilfred Shadbolt (Head Jailor & Assistant Tormentor) | Zak Stone |
| The Headsmen |
Andrew Ujifusa Devin Cole Kevin Angle |
| Yeomen of the Guard |
David Byron Lou Howe Jim Maltese Matt Pollock Matt Victory |
| Elsie Maynard (A Strolling Singer) | Alia Rosenstock |
| Phoebe Meryll (Sergeant Meryll's Daughter) | Ann Brown |
| Dame Carruthers (Housekeeper to the Tower) | Emily Ludmir |
| Kate (Her Niece) | Emily Donaldson |
| Townspeople |
Emily Donaldson Alix Hazel Natalie Ignacio Amy Lenander |