The (regular) puzzle we considered easiest (Come to Order) was in fact solved first overall, but was never solved by Team HRSFA. Conversely, the puzzle we considered hardest (Table Talk at Baker Street) was the first solved by Team HRSFA.
The last regular puzzle to be solved by any team, Four Grids, was the first to be solved by all four teams who remained to finish the hunt.
Seven puzzles (ingredients 5, 7, and 9; Mirror, Mirror; Sudokuro!; Four Grids; and Get Your Kicks) were never incorrectly answered. By contrast, ingredient 4 was incorrectly answered 18 times.
Severed Heads never checked an incorrect answer, either online or by phone.
Two teams solved the bonus puzzle: Team HRSFA, which used it to buy the answer to Come to Order, and Danger Zone, which used it to buy the answer to Another Interminable Online Riddle Game.
| Puzzle | Correct | Incorrect | First Solved | Last Solved | Median | ||
| Ingredient 1 | 4 | 10 | 13:27:01 | Danger Zone | 14:11:29 | Severed Heads | 13:57:06 |
| Ingredient 2 | 4 | 7 | 13:45:21 | Severed Heads | 15:02:53 | Danger Zone | 13:48:06 |
| Ingredient 3 | 4 | 10 | 13:40:25 | Danger Zone | 15:36:12 | plugh | 14:10:14 |
| Ingredient 4 | 4 | 18 | 13:43:05 | plugh | 17:25:55 | Team HRSFA | 15:29:59 |
| Ingredient 5 | 4 | 0 | 13:41:00 | Danger Zone | 14:00:52 | Severed Heads | 13:47:41 |
| Ingredient 6 | 4 | 9 | 13:45:38 | Danger Zone | 17:05:12 | Severed Heads | 14:29:58 |
| Ingredient 7 | 4 | 0 | 13:43:41 | Team HRSFA | 14:45:07 | Severed Heads | 13:47:29 |
| Ingredient 8 | 4 | 6 | 13:53:24 | Danger Zone | 16:13:17 | Team HRSFA | 14:27:33 |
| Ingredient 9 | 4 | 0 | 13:54:01 | plugh | 15:44:21 | Severed Heads | 14:03:47 |
| Ingredient 10 | 4 | 3 | 13:54:05 | Danger Zone | 17:55:23 | Team HRSFA | 14:27:45 |
| Come to Order | 3 | 7 | 14:18:05 | plugh | (never solved) | Team HRSFA | 15:36:22 |
| Mirror, Mirror | 4 | 0 | 14:30:30 | plugh | 18:20:55 | Severed Heads | 15:26:56 |
| Sudokuro! | 4 | 0 | 15:46:30 | Danger Zone | 19:43:37 | Severed Heads | 17:47:50 |
| Four Grids | 4 | 0 | 16:54:41 | Danger Zone | 17:45:04 | plugh | 17:14:33 |
| Table Talk at Baker Street | 4 | 1 | 15:14:36 | Team HRSFA | 21:07:45 | Severed Heads | 16:27:15 |
| We're Keebler, Not Hormel! | 4 | 2 | 15:57:21 | plugh | 19:32:07 | Severed Heads | 17:14:26 |
| Sorry, Wrong Letters | 4 | 2 | 14:58:56 | Danger Zone | 18:55:56 | Severed Heads | 16:52:44 |
| Get Your Kicks | 4 | 0 | 14:30:30 | plugh | 19:49:12 | Severed Heads | 17:50:40 |
| Another Interminable Online Riddle Game | 3 | 2 | 15:11:29 | plugh | (never solved) | Danger Zone | 18:26:12 |
| Look Out Ahead! | 3 | 5 | 16:21:35 | Danger Zone | (never solved) | Severed Heads | 18:54:44 |
| Meta | 3 | 4 | 18:11:41 | Danger Zone | (never solved) | plugh | 20:49:43 |
| Team | Correct | Incorrect | ||||
| Ingredients | ||||||
| Severed Heads | 10 | 0 | ||||
| Danger Zone | 10 | 10 | ||||
| plugh | 10 | 12 | ||||
| Team HRSFA | 10 | 41 | ||||
| Xena, Warrior Princess(es)!! | 2 | 0 | ||||
| Regular Puzzles | ||||||
| Severed Heads | 9 | 0 | ||||
| Danger Zone | 9 | 9 | ||||
| plugh | 10 | 2 | ||||
| Team HRSFA | 9 | 8 | ||||
| Xena, Warrior Princess(es)!! | 0 | 0 | ||||
| Time | Team | Puzzle | Answer | Source |
| 13:26:13 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 1 | 77 | check_answer |
| 13:26:36 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 1 | M | check_answer |
| 13:27:01 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 1 | 1110111 | check_answer |
| 13:38:47 | Xena, Warrior Princess(es)!! | Ingredient 1 | 1110111 | check_answer |
| 13:39:56 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 3 | 3330 | check_answer |
| 13:40:25 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 3 | 330 | check_answer |
| 13:40:42 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 2 | coffee concerto | check_answer |
| 13:41:00 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 5 | russia | check_answer |
| 13:41:10 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 2 | coffee | check_answer |
| 13:42:00 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 5 | russia | check_answer |
| 13:42:35 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 2 | cocoa | check_answer |
| 13:42:47 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 2 | cocoa concerto | check_answer |
| 13:43:05 | plugh | Ingredient 4 | truman | check_answer |
| 13:43:41 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 7 | BRUCE | check_answer |
| 13:45:21 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 2 | coffee cantata | check_answer |
| 13:45:25 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 2 | coffee cantata | check_answer |
| 13:45:38 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 6 | promisedland | check_answer |
| 13:45:57 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 7 | bruce | check_answer |
| 13:46:56 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 1 | w | check_answer |
| 13:48:03 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 1 | 119 | check_answer |
| 13:48:27 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 1 | tin | check_answer |
| 13:49:02 | plugh | Ingredient 7 | bruce | check_answer |
| 13:50:37 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | Harry Potter | check_answer |
| 13:50:47 | plugh | Ingredient 2 | coffee cantata | check_answer |
| 13:52:08 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 1 | w | check_answer |
| 13:52:20 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 1 | W | check_answer |
| 13:52:38 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 1 | 1110111 | check_answer |
| 13:53:22 | plugh | Ingredient 5 | russia | check_answer |
| 13:53:24 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 8 | clairol | check_answer |
| 13:54:01 | plugh | Ingredient 9 | stripes | check_answer |
| 13:54:05 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 10 | CHOCOLATESYRUP | check_answer |
| 13:54:36 | plugh | Ingredient 1 | sos | check_answer |
| 13:55:36 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 8 | A Collie | check_answer |
| 13:55:57 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 8 | A COLLIE | check_answer |
| 13:56:48 | plugh | Ingredient 1 | cookie | check_answer |
| 13:57:03 | plugh | Ingredient 1 | elf | check_answer |
| 13:57:12 | Xena, Warrior Princess(es)!! | Ingredient 2 | coffee cantata | check_answer |
| 13:59:04 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 9 | stripes | check_answer |
| 13:59:53 | plugh | Ingredient 8 | clairol | check_answer |
| 14:00:22 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | 252 | check_answer |
| 14:00:52 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | 254 | check_answer |
| 14:00:52 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 5 | russia | check_answer |
| 14:01:15 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | 255 | check_answer |
| 14:01:34 | plugh | Ingredient 1 | 1110111 | check_answer |
| 14:02:24 | plugh | Ingredient 6 | promised land | check_answer |
| 14:03:15 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 8 | Barenaked Ladies | check_answer |
| 14:03:22 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | temporal 52 | check_answer |
| 14:04:56 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | 210 | check_answer |
| 14:04:58 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 8 | CLAIEOL | check_answer |
| 14:05:13 | plugh | Ingredient 10 | chocolate syrup | check_answer |
| 14:08:30 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 9 | stripes | check_answer |
| 14:10:09 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 3 | 330 | check_answer |
| 14:10:19 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 3 | 330 | check_answer |
| 14:11:29 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 1 | 1110111 | check_answer |
| 14:18:05 | plugh | Come to Order | WET INGREDIENTS | call |
| 14:21:10 | Danger Zone | Come to Order | wax ingredient | call |
| 14:21:49 | Danger Zone | Come to Order | beeswax | call |
| 14:21:59 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | the footbing | check_answer |
| 14:22:08 | Danger Zone | Come to Order | tallow | call |
| 14:22:35 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | bing the foot | check_answer |
| 14:26:47 | Danger Zone | Come to Order | wat ingredient | call |
| 14:29:40 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 2 | coffee nocturne | check_answer |
| 14:30:30 | plugh | Get Your Kicks | husband | call |
| 14:30:30 | plugh | Mirror, Mirror | workplace | call |
| 14:37:06 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 8 | pie | check_answer |
| 14:38:50 | Danger Zone | Come to Order | wax ingredients | call |
| 14:39:47 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | dirty | check_answer |
| 14:40:16 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | 841 | check_answer |
| 14:41:46 | Danger Zone | Come to Order | wat ingredients | call |
| 14:42:37 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | 789 | check_answer |
| 14:43:30 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | Harry_Potter | check_answer |
| 14:43:47 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | harry potter | check_answer |
| 14:43:58 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | prince | check_answer |
| 14:45:07 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 7 | bruce | check_answer |
| 14:45:40 | Danger Zone | Come to Order | milk and honey | call |
| 14:45:52 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | Bill | check_answer |
| 14:46:24 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | Debbie | check_answer |
| 14:50:17 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 10 | chocolate syrup | check_answer |
| 14:53:11 | Team HRSFA | Table Talk at Baker Street | -130 | call |
| 14:55:14 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 8 | Clairol | check_answer |
| 14:57:32 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 6 | Promised Land | check_answer |
| 14:58:56 | Danger Zone | Sorry, Wrong Letters | eleventh | call |
| 14:59:55 | Danger Zone | Mirror, Mirror | workplace | call |
| 15:01:48 | plugh | Sorry, Wrong Letters | eleventh | call |
| 15:02:25 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 2 | coffeeatanos | check_answer |
| 15:02:37 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 2 | coffeeatanose | check_answer |
| 15:02:53 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 2 | coffeecantata | check_answer |
| 15:04:58 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 8 | let it be | check_answer |
| 15:05:09 | Danger Zone | Ingredient 4 | truman | check_answer |
| 15:10:53 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | zero | check_answer |
| 15:11:09 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | one | check_answer |
| 15:11:22 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | two | check_answer |
| 15:11:29 | plugh | Another Interminable Online Riddle Game | courses of instruction | call |
| 15:11:34 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | two | check_answer |
| 15:11:49 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | three | check_answer |
| 15:14:04 | Danger Zone | Come to Order | wet ingredients | call |
| 15:14:36 | Team HRSFA | Table Talk at Baker Street | fusion and fission | call |
| 15:18:17 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | mouse | check_answer |
| 15:18:34 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | circuit | check_answer |
| 15:18:48 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | analog | check_answer |
| 15:19:17 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | nine | check_answer |
| 15:26:23 | plugh | We're Keebler, Not Hormel! | chalk | call |
| 15:36:12 | plugh | Ingredient 3 | 330 | check_answer |
| 15:37:49 | plugh | We're Keebler, Not Hormel! | anion | call |
| 15:44:21 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 9 | stripes | check_answer |
| 15:46:30 | Danger Zone | Sudokuro! | chimera | call |
| 15:53:57 | Team HRSFA | Mirror, Mirror | WORKPLACE | call |
| 15:54:49 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 4 | TRUMAN | check_answer |
| 15:55:11 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | Deborah | check_answer |
| 15:57:21 | plugh | We're Keebler, Not Hormel! | CARBONATE | call |
| 15:58:40 | Severed Heads | Come to Order | WETINGREDIENTS | call |
| 16:01:52 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | potter | check_answer |
| 16:02:08 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | harry potter | check_answer |
| 16:04:28 | plugh | Sudokuro! | chimera | call |
| 16:09:50 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 10 | holy crap!! | check_answer |
| 16:09:55 | Danger Zone | Table Talk at Baker Street | fusionandfission | call |
| 16:11:35 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | dirty harry | check_answer |
| 16:11:48 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | dirty harry potter | check_answer |
| 16:11:58 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | dirty | check_answer |
| 16:12:41 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | dirty | check_answer |
| 16:13:17 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 8 | clairol | check_answer |
| 16:21:35 | Danger Zone | Look Out Ahead! | palette | call |
| 16:37:07 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 10 | random | check_answer |
| 16:37:21 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 10 | random numbers | check_answer |
| 16:44:36 | plugh | Table Talk at Baker Street | fusionandfission | call |
| 16:45:24 | Danger Zone | Another Interminable Online Riddle Game | breakin | call |
| 16:54:41 | Danger Zone | Four Grids | even out | call |
| 16:55:47 | Severed Heads | Four Grids | even out | call |
| 16:58:33 | Danger Zone | Get Your Kicks | husband | call |
| 17:05:12 | Severed Heads | Ingredient 6 | promisedland | check_answer |
| 17:14:06 | Team HRSFA | We're Keebler, Not Hormel! | carbonate | call |
| 17:14:46 | Danger Zone | We're Keebler, Not Hormel! | carbonate | call |
| 17:15:47 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | box | check_answer |
| 17:16:01 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | harrypotter | check_answer |
| 17:16:15 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | potterharry | check_answer |
| 17:24:58 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | luther | check_answer |
| 17:25:55 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 4 | truman | check_answer |
| 17:33:19 | Team HRSFA | Four Grids | evenout | call |
| 17:43:19 | plugh | Look Out Ahead! | palette | call |
| 17:45:04 | plugh | Four Grids | evenout | call |
| 17:46:38 | Severed Heads | Another Interminable Online Riddle Game | courses of instruction | call |
| 17:49:31 | plugh | Meta | italian white eggplant | call |
| 17:50:45 | plugh | Meta | chinese white eggplant | call |
| 17:51:37 | plugh | Meta | snow white eggplant | call |
| 17:52:09 | Danger Zone | Another Interminable Online Riddle Game | terminable | call |
| 17:54:21 | Team HRSFA | Sorry, Wrong Letters | one eleventh | call |
| 17:55:23 | Team HRSFA | Ingredient 10 | chocolate syrup | check_answer |
| 18:01:45 | Team HRSFA | Sorry, Wrong Letters | NO ONE | call |
| 18:05:25 | plugh | Meta | ornamental white eggplant | call |
| 18:11:41 | Danger Zone | Meta | organicwhiteeggplant | call |
| 18:20:55 | Severed Heads | Mirror, Mirror | workplace | call |
| 18:42:47 | Team HRSFA | Get Your Kicks | husband | call |
| 18:43:41 | Team HRSFA | Sorry, Wrong Letters | eleventh | call |
| 18:53:12 | Team HRSFA | Look Out Ahead! | balette | call |
| 18:55:56 | Severed Heads | Sorry, Wrong Letters | eleventh | call |
| 19:05:47 | Team HRSFA | Another Interminable Online Riddle Game | courses of instruction | call |
| 19:08:50 | Team HRSFA | Look Out Ahead! | ballate | call |
| 19:15:17 | Team HRSFA | Look Out Ahead! | ballade | call |
| 19:20:33 | Team HRSFA | Look Out Ahead! | ballute | call |
| 19:31:13 | Team HRSFA | Sudokuro! | CHIMERA | call |
| 19:32:07 | Severed Heads | We're Keebler, Not Hormel! | carbonate | call |
| 19:43:37 | Severed Heads | Sudokuro! | chimera | call |
| 19:49:12 | Severed Heads | Get Your Kicks | husband | call |
| 20:00:49 | Team HRSFA | Look Out Ahead! | batiste | call |
| 20:06:10 | Team HRSFA | Look Out Ahead! | palette | call |
| 20:06:55 | Team HRSFA | Meta | organic white eggplant | call |
| 21:07:45 | Severed Heads | Table Talk at Baker Street | fusionandfission | call |
| 21:32:32 | Severed Heads | Meta | organicwhiteeggplant | call |