|
Rights
Groups Won't Get Seats at Guantánamo Base Tribunals
The New York Times
By
Neil A. Lewis
February 24, 2004
WASHINGTON, Feb.
23 - Pentagon officials say they do not expect to be able to provide
space for representatives of human rights advocacy groups to observe
any military tribunals at the naval base at Guantánamo
Bay, Cuba, prompting complaints from those groups that the military
is trying to shut out potential critics.
In letters last week
to Amnesty International, Human Rights First and Human Rights
Watch, a senior military official said it was unlikely that they
would be allowed to attend any military tribunals at Guantánamo.
The official, Brig. Gen. Thomas L. Hemingway, a chief legal adviser
in the office of military commissions, wrote that space would
be limited if and when tribunals were held at Guantánamo.
"It is expected
that limited courtroom seating and other logistical issues will
preclude attendance by many who desire to observe military commission
proceedings," he wrote.
General Hemingway
noted that there would be seats for the news media as well as
for representatives of the International Red Cross.
Last Friday, the
groups wrote to the defense secretary, Donald H. Rumsfeld, asking
him to reconsider the matter, saying, "There can be no legitimate
governmental reason for denying our access to the proceedings."
Wendy Patten, a Washington
representative of Human Rights Watch, said Monday that the reasons
given were implausible and that the groups should be entitled
to at least one seat that they could rotate among themselves.
She noted that the Bush administration had defended itself from
critics of the possible tribunals by saying that the proceedings
were to be open to wide scrutiny.
A senior military
official said the deliberations over whether to allow the presence
of human rights groups involved issues other than the availability
of seats in the courtroom and the overflow room where some reporters
will be able to view the proceedings on closed-circuit television.
The official, who spoke about the deliberations on the condition
of anonymity, said that planners considered the problems of security
as well as limited food and housing facilities at the Guantánamo
base, which is in an isolated location on the southeastern tip
of Cuba.
The official acknowledged,
however, that there would probably be arrangements for some members
of Congress to attend the trials and perhaps for officials of
organizations that represent victims of the Sept. 11 terrorist
attacks.
President Bush has
designated six of the 650 prisoners at Guantánamo as eligible
for trial but there have, as yet, been no specific plans to conduct
any tribunals. More than 80 members of the news media, both from
the United States and abroad, are expected to attend any tribunals,
officials said.
|