Making Harvard a Truly Supportive Community
by Adam P. Fagen
submitted to The Harvard Crimson
abridged version published November 20, 1997
Last week's death of a first-year graduate student is a real tragedy for
the entire Harvard community, and should serve as a wake-up call for us
all to examine our educational and social environment. Unfortunately,
this is not the only such incident in recent years; let us work to make it
the last. We must look closely at the experiences of students to identify
any underlying problems with our system. Especially since we may never
know the factors which led to this - or any other - tragic event, we must
look at all aspects of academic and personal life. In our grief, we
should carefully reevaluate the culture and pressures students often face,
enabling us to take real steps to prevent such a tragedy from happening
again.
There are many resources on this campus which can help students address
personal challenges and difficulties. Mental Health Service, the Bureau
of Study Counsel, In Common, Room 13, Response, friends, and family can
provide great help for those who seek them out. But they can do very
little to help those who suffer in isolation.
Students who do seek help and support should not be discouraged, whether
openly or subtly. Rather, they should be encouraged to make use of these
valuable resources. No one should be made to feel like a failure when
they seek out assistance. Few of us would be here without support from
family and friends. And few can make it through their entire educational
and professional careers without continuing encouragement.
Even more important, though, is that we devote ourselves to eliminating
such stresses and problems at their source. The Harvard environment and
institution should help us to overcome our difficulties, not cause them.
We cannot rely upon counseling and support services to make up for the
limitations of our community, but must instead work to make Harvard a
truly supportive place. University support networks are necessary, but
should not serve as a band-aid for underlying institutional
imperfections.
The free and open exchange of ideas is integral to our academic mission.
Such freedom and inclusion must extend to all aspects of the University
and to all members of our community. We must care what all members of the
community experience and believe, listening to their ideas and humbly and
unselfishly implementing appropriate solutions to address any problems.
Throughout this institution, significant and avoidable stresses are
happening every day. Some victims are more able to deal with them than
others, so we may not all hear about them as often as they occur. But we
must all stand up for the rights and responsibilities of every member of
our community. No one should ever be told that they are worthless or
stupid nor fear repercussion for speaking against those in power. No one
should ever suffer verbal, sexual, or physical abuse or harassment nor be
told that the things they care most about are unimportant. No one should
be told that their viewpoint and opinion do not matter nor be forced into
following arbitrary programs. No one should feel they are not able to
speak freely nor lack a forum in which to do so.
We must all be conscious of how our words and actions may affect others
and be sensitive to different viewpoints and backgrounds. Even if we do
not mean a comment or action to be taken personally, be aware that it
sometimes may be.
We must have a real expectation that we will not be victims of
mistreatment or inappropriate behavior on the part of others. And if such
transgressions do occur, there must be an unbiased and real mechanism for
dealing with them without fear of reprisal against the victims. Students,
faculty, and staff must all be responsible for their actions and be held
accountable for their behavior when it goes over the line. Too often,
problems remain hidden with many victims suffering in silence and others
choosing to leave. Tragically, a few students are so affected that they
give up their dreams or even their lives.
As we enjoy the enormous benefits and high quality of this university, we
must be aware of the stresses it can put on all of us, both personal and
collective. The tragic events of last week should remind us that not
everything is perfect. But, working together as a community, we can and
must openly address our shortcomings to enhance the academic and personal
experience for all of us. Our commitment to excellence demands nothing
less.
Adam P. Fagen is a fifth-year graduate student and President of the
GSAS Graduate Student Council.
|