About HIPJ
HIPJ homepage
HIPJ FAQ
Weblog Archives

US News
NY Times
Wall Street Journal
Washington Post
Washington Times
Boston Globe
LA Times
ABC News
CBS News
MSNBC
Fox News
CSPAN
CNN
Reuters

World News
BBC (UK) News
The Independent (UK)
The Guardian (UK)
The Hindu(India)
The Indian Express
The Dawn(Pakistan)
Globe and Mail (Canada)
Ha'aretz(Israel)
Jerusalem Post
Le Monde(France)
Mail and Guardian(South Africa)
Moscow Times (Russia)
Christian Science Monitor
United Press International
Colombia Times

Alternative News
Indymedia(US)
Indymedia(UK)
Z Magazine
Counterpunch
Democracy Now
Corporation Watch

Magazines/ Journals
The Economist
Foreign Affairs
Foreign Policy
Business Week
News Week
Time Magazine
The Atlantic Monthly
Harpers
The New Republic
Outlook India
Frontline (India)

Harvard Publications
The Crimson
The Harvard Independent
The Harvard College Economist
Harvard Focus Europe
Diversity and Distinction
Flare
Harvard International Review
Harvard Perspective

Harvard Organizations
Harvard Friends of Amnesty International
Harvard Living Wage Campaign
Harvard Students Against Sweatshops

Archives By Category
About HIPJ (1)
Africa (1)
Asia (1)
Daily News Summaries (61)
Discussions (2)
Economics (2)
Environment (1)
Europe (1)
Events (5)
HIPJ Organizational (6)
Harvard (2)
India (1)
Iraq (38)
Israel and Palestine (5)
Latin America (7)
Media (4)
Militarization (6)
Talks (2)
US (16)

Last 20 Posts
13.10.04 - Carlyle Group, Iraq Reparations and Conflicts of Interests (31)
05.10.04 - How the White House Embraced Disputed Arms Intelligence (31)
29.09.04 - Baghdad Year Zero (19)
12.08.04 - The Googlian Knot (50)
26.07.04 - Scott Ritter Article (57)
23.07.04 - U.S. Army Offers Breast Implants as Incentive (47)
19.07.04 - Allawi shot inmates in cold blood, say witnesses (670)
17.07.04 - Academics Targeted in Iraq (75)
12.07.04 - Giuliani Destroys Evidence in Unsolved Anthrax Murder Case, Gets Adulation (94)
12.07.04 - 2 Scapegoats for the Price of One? (139)
03.07.04 - What the Handover Means (0)
21.06.04 - Lawyer for Abu Ghraib Accused Claims "Israeli Methods" Used Under Pressure from Commanders and CIA (165)
16.06.04 - Council on Foreign Relations Helps Kissinger Deny his Criminal Past (63)
15.06.04 - Who Are the Moral Relativists? (117)
12.06.04 - Interrogators hired for Iraq despite ban (154)
09.06.04 - Birdcage Liner: CIA Officials Suffer Memory Loss (203)
09.06.04 - Shaken, Stirred, and On the Rocks - Soldiers Fall Ill, Commit Suicide After Downing Military's Drug Cocktail (260)
08.06.04 - CHALABI MAKES OFF WITH SADDAM'S SCANDALOUS FILES (221)
06.06.04 - Birdcage Liner Bad for America's Health (242)
06.06.04 - U.S. Military Luring Kids With Video Games (154)




www.iraqbodycount.org



« Previous Entry | Next Entry »

Dershowitz Through the Ages.

There has recently been a controversy on campus regarding allegations of plagiarism in Alan Dershowitz's book The Case for Israel. If you are interested in that story there is fairly extensive coverage on Norman Finkelstein's website. Finkelstein is known for exposing that the book From Time Immemorial by Joan Peters in 1980s was largely a hoax. Readers can look at the evidence and make up their own minds about that controversy.

However, in this entry I'd rather focus on another controversy involving Alan Dershowitz, that Noam Chomsky made reference to during his talk last week that HIPJ co-sponsored. This has to do with a series of letters that were sent to the Boston Globe in 1973 where Dershowitz made allegations about the Israeli civil rights leader Israel Shahak which Noam Chomsky responded to. Please forgive (and comment on) any typos, I am retyping this from a hard copy. Again, readers can make up their own minds.

Click here to see the text from 1973 letters in The Boston Globe.

Here is the first letter to the Boston Globe on April 29, 1973 by Alan Dershowitz:

SHAHAK, BEST PROOF OF FREEDOM OF SPEECH

On April 18, you published an interview in which Israel Shahak characterized Israel as a "racist" society. Your reporter described Dr. Shahak as "chairman of the Israel League for Human and Civil Rights."

Shahak is not the chairman of that organization. In 1970, he was overwhelmingly defeated for re-election to that post. When he was chairman of the League, it was a tiny organization composed primarily of members of two Maoist organizations, Matzpen and Rakach (though Shahak himself belongs to neither). As soon as the membership was permitted to expand and include a broader political spectrum - over Shahak's vehement protests - Shahak and his clique were ousted. I suspect that it was not your reporter's fault that he characterized Shahak as current chairman of the League, since Shahak has continued to misinform the public about his status since his ouster.

Let no one believe that Shahak is a civil libertarian. He is the furthest thing from it. A civil libertarian defends the rights of those with whom he disagrees as vehemently as those with whom he agrees (consider, for example, the American Civil Liberties Union's frequent defense of Nazis and right wingers). Shahak has never defended the rights with whom he disagrees politically; nor has he ever attacked the practices of those with whom he agrees politically. He is about as much of a civil libertarian as are Communists who defend only the rights of other Communists or Ku Klux Klanners who only defend the rights of other Klanners.

Shahak's approach is well illustrated by the content of his interview. He calls Israel "racist" because it designates its residents by their religion. Most countries in the world, of course, do the same thing. Every Arab country draws distinctions between Moslems and non-Moslems. Indeed, even Lebanon, probably the most liberal of Arab countries, explicitly requires certain of its high officials to be Moslem and others to be Christian. (Jews - even Anti-Zionist Jews like Dr. Shahak - are excluded from attaining these offices.) Other Arab countries exclude all non-Moslems from office, and from other important privileges and rights. There are no such exclusions under Israeli law. A Moslem, a Druze, or a Christian could, theoretically, become Prime Minister of Israel; and many non-Jews do, in fact, hold high office nationally as well as locally. Most countries in the world - and every single Arab country - could learn a great deal from Israel's handling of its minority population.

Of course, Israel is a Jewish country. In a world with numerous Moslem, Catholic and Protestant countries, why should there not be one country where Jewish values and culture predominate? As long as there is no discrimination against other minorities, Israel's Jewishness is to be applauded not condemned.

The very best proof of Israel's commitment to liberty is that it permits hate-mongers such as Shahak - and other Israeli-Arab critics of Israel - to travel throughout the world on Israeli passports spewing forth their venom. Can one think of any Arab country that would permit a Jewish critic publicly to attack its regime?

ALAN DERSHOWITZ
Professor of Law
Harvard.

On May 17, 1973, The Boston Globe published this response, a letter from Noam Chomsky:

SHAHAK A MAN OF HONOR AND PRINCIPLE

In a letter April 29, Alan Dershowitz raised objections to the interview with Dr. Israer Shahak in The Globe April 18.

According to Dershowitz, Shahak was not telling the truth when he identified himself as chairman of the Israel League for Human and Civil Rights, since he was "overwhelmingly defeated for reelection to that post" in November, 1970. The facts, as far as I can determine them, are as follows.

In November 1972 (not 1970), the Youth Department of the Israel Labor Party distributed an internal memorandum requesting members to register "for the purpose of enabling our party to have a predominant influence in the League for Human Rights." The Labor Party offered to cover the expenses of the membership dues, in this "national operation." On Nov. 16, 1972 several hundred members of the Labor Party Youth Group had appeared at a general meeting of the League, insisted on being registered at once as members, voted out the leadership of this small civil rights organization, and proceeded to pass a resolution denouncing the treatment of Jews in the Soviet Union. The Israeli Courts, quite properly, declared the events of the meeting null and void. While the litigation continues, the leadership of the League remains as before under Israeli law. It is these events to which Dershowitz refers when he writes that "as soon as the membership was permitted to expand include a broader political spectrum - over vehement protests - Shahak and his clique was ousted."

The League has announced it remains open, as in the past, to all individuals concerned with civil rights, who may apply... on an individual basis. One might observe that, in contrast, the Labor Party excludes Arabs from membership.

Evidently, no open organization can withstand such tactics for long. If such methods were used to take over the American Civil Liberties Union in a "national operation" of some mass political organization, Dershowitz would be the first to protest. It is remarkable that he is willing to associate himself with such tactics when they are employed in an admitted effort to enable the largest political party in Israel "to have a predominant influence in the League for Human Rights."

Dershowitz then proceeds to assert that Shahak is "about as much of a civil libertarian as are the Communists who defend only the rights of other Communists," and he claims that "Shahak has never defended the rights of those with whom he disagrees politically." The facts are quite different. Israel Shahak came to Israel from Poland, where he had been in a Nazi concentration camp. He is a distinguished scientist at the Hebrew University, a man steeped in the Jewish tradition, politically rather conservative, not a communist or a socialist. As anyone familiar with Israeli society would recognize at once, he is a member of the most privileged social group in the country, while to the right of the official views of the dominant Labor Party on many social and political issues. He has courageously defended the rights of the oppressed and underprivileged: Arabs, Oriental Jews, political dissidents, and others who differ from him markedly not only in political belief but also social status. He is a man of honor and principle who needs no lessons from Alan Dershowitz or anyone else on what it means to be a civil libertarian.

According to Dershowitz, Shahak calls Israel "racist" on the grounds that it "designates its residents by their religion" as most other countries do. This is nonsense. Shahak has accumulated and made public extensive documentation on legal and institutional discrimination and on discriminatory administrative and social practices. Rather than attending to this evidence, or seeking to refute it if is incorrect or misleading, Dershowitz has chosen to distort beyond recognition what Shahak has said and done to villify him as a "hate-monger" who "spews forth (his) venom" against Israel. His resort to such tactics and his refusal to consider the actual evidence that Shahak has presented speaks for itself, I am afraid.

NOAM CHOMSKY
Cambridge

Here is Dershowitz's reply on May 25, 1973 in The Boston Globe.

DERSHOWITZ REPLIES

I was not surprised at the belligerent tone of Noam Chomsky's response (May 17) to my letter regarding Israel Shahak (April 29). Though Chomsky and I have been allies in numerous cases, I have seen over the years that Chomsky will stop at nothing in attacking those who support Israel or in defending those who attack it. As evidence of that, consider his statement that the Israeli courts declared the League for Human Rights election void and that "the leadership of the League remains as before under Israeli law". That is totally false. The truth is that the Tel Aviv district Court, in an opinion by Judge Levenberg, ruled that the election was legal and that Shahak had been validly defeated. I challenge Chomsky to cite me any documentary evidence to the contrary!

Chomsky completely distorts the history leading up to the 1972 election. He neglects to mention that since its foundation in the 1930s, the league was always a broadly based civil liberties organization until Shahak's clique took it over in 1970 and used it as an anti-zionist political tool. I see nothing wrong on the part of members of the Israeli labor movement to convert that organization back into one that truly stands for civil liberties. Nor would I object if large numbers of persons - who were committed to civil liberties - tried to change the American Civil Liberties Union by democratic means.

Chomsky disputes my statement that Shahak defends the civil liberties only of those with whom he agrees politically. I again challenge Chomsky to cite me instances where Shahak (or the League when it was under his domination) ever supported the rights of those who disagreed with the anti-zionist political views of the League. Why did the League - when it was under Shahak's domination - refuse to condemn the execution of Jews in Iraq or the oppression of Jews in the Soviet Union? I'm afraid that both Shahak and Chomsky do need lessons on what it means to be a civil libertarian.

ALAN DERSHOWITZ
Professor of Law
Cambridge

Here is Chomsky's second reply on June 5, 1973 in the Boston Globe.



NOAM CHOMSKY
MIT
Cambridge
IN DEFENSE OF SHAHAK

In a further attempt to discredit the Israel League for Human Rights and its chairman, Israel Shahak, Alan Dershowitz asserts (May 25) that "the Tel Aviv District Court, in an opinion by Judge Lovenberg, ruled that the election (of Nov.16 1972) was legal and that Shahak had been validly defeated." He challenges me to cite "any documentary evidence to the contrary."

I quote from the opinion of Judge Lovenberg, Nov. 26, 1972: "The meeting called for Nov.16, 1972, in the opinion of the court, was not held properly, and no conclusions or actions are to be drawn from it." On April 8, Judge Lovenberg reaffirmed that the results of the November meeting "were not recognized as binding by this Court." In this opinion he refers to the "former committee" (that is, Shahak and his colleagues), which continues to function, as "those who now direct" the League. I have the Court documents in my posession, and will gladly show them to any interested person.

Dershowitz sees "nothing wrong with a desire on the part of members of the Israeli labor movement to convert" the League. Recall the uncontested facts. In an internal memorandum, the Labor Party urged members to join the League (with dues paid by the party) "for the purpose of enabling our party to have a predominant influence" in the League. There is no mention of any commitment to civil liberties. Rather, this is described as a "state duty." It is remarkable that Dershowitz sees this as an effort to change the League "by democratic means." Evidently, no open organization of dissent can survive such tactics on the part of the ruling party.

Dershowitz reiterates that Shahak is no civil libertarian, and finally produces his evidence: the Israeli League did not "condemn the execution of Jews in Iraq or the oppression of Jews in the Soviet Union." By similar logic, we can prove that the ACLU is not committed to civil liberties, since it does not condemn the treatment of political prisoners in Indonesia or Kurds in Iraq. Plainly, the only valid criticism of the ACLU would be that it refuses on political grounds to defend civil liberties in the United States. Dershowitz cites not one relevant case to support his allegations against the League and its chairman. These charges are thus revealed to be mere slander, on a par with his continued assertion that Shahak was voted out of office in a legal election.

It is important that the central issue not be obscured. Dr. Sharak and the Israel League, acting with courage and honor, have produced substantial evidence on violations of human and civil rights by the Israeli government, avoiding no relevant instances to my knowledge. Apparently unable to refute the facts, Dershowitz has chosen to defame the man, in a manner which is as familiar at is deplorable.


Posted by: Phil at 12 : 21 PM | Comments? (97) | LINK

Comment Policy: HIPJ loves comments even if the commentary doesn't always love HIPJ. The managers of this blog reserve the right to delete comments which are derogatory, racist, offensive, rude, contain personal attacks or are just plain off topic and weird. If you think that your comment has been unjustly removed or if you see a comment which should be removed please email hipj@hcs.harvard.edu.

Comments

Thanks for posting this! I was just listening to a tape of this talk and most of my google-searching on "fraud" and "Dershowitz" simply brought up his more recent engagement with Finkelstein. These letters are quite illuminating... there really is nothing new under the sun!

Posted by: cullen at June 22, 2004 04:32 PM

Domination redhead fetish bank , female domination lips japanese bondage . Domination erotica bondage girls , rope bondage slut ball torture . Fetish stories lover sex torture , free femdom cum sadism . Latex bondage latina bdsm stories , bondage gear pregnant femdom drawings . Smoking fetish mpg fetish sex , water bondage webcam fetish bank . Bondage wizard jpg bondage girls , bondage sex jpg pantyhose bondage . Bdsm art tight fetish stories , fetish wear babe femdom strapon .

Bondage videos bikini free femdom , free bondage pics gallery sex bondage . Sadism dildo tentacles , rope bondage analsex latex bondage . Torture drawings cock torture , balloon fetish fucking women in bondage . Sado girls smoking fetish , tentacle sex threesome japanese bondage . Sock fetish gangbang free bdsm , bdsm art woman diaper fetish . Sock fetish xxx bondage movies , bondage toys bitch women in bondage . Bondage equipment pussy breast bondage , fetish thumbs bondage stories .

Posted by: foot fetish at October 20, 2004 11:36 AM

Hello there,

Iwas browsing the web and found this blog. Some interesting quotes. Keep them coming!

Alice
credit

Posted by: credit at November 2, 2004 01:44 PM

Guten Tag - Hier ist ein sehr schooner Site. Cheap Staples

Danke!
Bob Staple

Posted by: Bob Staple at November 17, 2004 12:29 AM

Overdrawn? But I still have checks left!
Home Equity Loan Rate http://www.home-equity-loan-x.com

Posted by: Home Equity Loan Rate at November 17, 2004 01:17 AM

If you eat a live frog in the morning, nothing worse will happen to
either of you for the rest of the day.
Cash Advance http://www.paydayloans.be

Posted by: Cash Advance at November 18, 2004 05:14 AM

The Good Ship Enterprise (to the tune of The Good Ship Lollipop)

On the good ship Enterprise
Every week there's a new surprise
Where the Romulans lurk
And the Klingons often go berserk.

Yes, the good ship Enterprise
There's excitement anywhere it flies
Where Tribbles play
And Nurse Chapel never gets her way.

See Captain Kirk standing on the bridge,
Mr. Spock is at his side.
The weekly menace, ooh-ooh
It gets fried, scattered far and wide.

It's the good ship Enterprise
Heading out where danger lies
And you live in dread
If you're wearing a shirt that's red.
-- Doris Robin and Karen Trimble of The L.A. Filkharmonics
Payday Loans http://www.paydayloans.be

Posted by: Payday Loans at November 18, 2004 10:57 PM

After his Ignoble Disgrace, Satan was being expelled from
Heaven. As he passed through the Gates, he paused a moment in thought,
and turned to God and said, A new creature called Man, I hear, is soon
to be created.
This is true, He replied.
He will need laws, said the Demon slyly.
What! You, his appointed Enemy for all Time! You ask for the
right to make his laws?
Oh, no! Satan replied, I ask only that he be allowed to
make his own.
It was so granted.
-- Ambrose Bierce, The Devil's Dictionary
Mortgage Loan http://www.refinance-mortgage-com.com

Posted by: Mortgage Loan at November 20, 2004 11:57 AM

All the world's a VAX,
And all the coders merely butchers;
They have their exits and their entrails;
And one int in his time plays many widths,
His sizeof being _N bytes. At first the infant,
Mewling and puking in the Regent's arms.
And then the whining schoolboy, with his Sun,
And shining morning face, creeping like slug
Unwillingly to school.
-- A Very Annoyed PDP-11
Credit Report http://credit-report.se.com

Posted by: Credit Report at November 21, 2004 06:36 AM

Nondeterminism means never having to say you are wrong.
Cash Advance http://www.cashadvance.be

Posted by: Cash Advance at November 23, 2004 10:18 AM

Don't take life so serious, son, it ain't nohow permanent.
-- Walt Kelly
Cash Advance Loan http://www.cashadvance.be

Posted by: Cash Advance Loan at November 24, 2004 03:05 AM

Why You Can't Run When There's Trouble in the Office:
No matter where you stand, no matter how far or fast you flee,
when it hits the fan, as much as possible will be propelled in your
direction, and almost none will be returned to the source.
-- John L. Shelton
Direct TV http://www.direct-tv-com.com

Posted by: Direct TV at November 24, 2004 07:10 PM

Hello folks nice blog youre running

Posted by: lolita at January 19, 2005 08:37 PM

Hey

I agree with what you're saying. Thanks for sharing the info with us.

Posted by: webcam at March 2, 2005 06:10 PM

In your free time, check some helpful info about auto loan auto loan http://www.doobu.com/auto-loan.html cash loan cash loan http://www.doobu.com/cash-loan.html college loan college loan http://www.doobu.com/college-loan.html home finance home finance http://www.doobu.com/home-finance.html home mortgage home mortgage http://www.doobu.com/home-mortgage.html loans calculator loans calculator http://www.doobu.com/loans-calculator.html mortgage mortgage http://www.doobu.com/mortgage.html mortgage loan mortgage loan http://www.doobu.com/mortgage-loan.html mortgage rates mortgage rates http://www.doobu.com/mortgage-rates.html payday advance payday advance http://www.doobu.com/payday-advance.html payday advance loan payday advance loan http://www.doobu.com/payday-advance-loan.html payday cash loan payday cash loan http://www.doobu.com/payday-cash-loan.html refinancing refinancing http://www.doobu.com/refinancing.html reverse mortgage reverse mortgage http://www.doobu.com/reverse-mortgage.html second mortgage second mortgage http://www.doobu.com/second-mortgage.html second mortgages second mortgages http://www.doobu.com/second-mortgages.html student loan student loan http://www.doobu.com/student-loan.html best mortgage rates best mortgage rates http://www.doobu.com/best-mortgage-rates.html home equity loans home equity loans http://www.doobu.com/home-equity-loans.html home financing home financing http://www.doobu.com/home-financing.html interest rates interest rates http://www.doobu.com/interest-rates.html jumbo loan jumbo loan http://www.doobu.com/jumbo-loan.html jumbo loans jumbo loans http://www.doobu.com/jumbo-loans.html jumbo mortgage jumbo mortgage http://www.doobu.com/jumbo-mortgage.html loans loans http://www.doobu.com/loans.html mortgage calculator mortgage calculator http://www.doobu.com/mortgage-calculator.html mortgage loans mortgage loans http://www.doobu.com/mortgage-loans.html mortgage rate mortgage rate http://www.doobu.com/mortgage-rate.html mortgage refinance mortgage refinance http://www.doobu.com/mortgage-refinance.html mortgages mortgages http://www.doobu.com/mortgages.html payday payday http://www.doobu.com/payday.html payday cash advance payday cash advance http://www.doobu.com/payday-cash-advance.html personal loan personal loan http://www.doobu.com/personal-loan.html personal loans personal loans http://www.doobu.com/personal-loans.html refinance mortgage refinance mortgage http://www.doobu.com/refinance-mortgage.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!

Posted by: mortgage rates at March 5, 2005 04:17 AM

Good Point. Anyways, this was where i met her. You can join for free as well www.redtricircle.com

Posted by: click here at March 12, 2005 04:07 AM

da671f58b4399f6b5f5a759f77e41a11 d2c9e639c.

Posted by: d83c5e at March 16, 2005 11:54 AM

Omg thats right! Please come see me and my friends! ;)

Posted by: watch moi at March 16, 2005 05:44 PM

I wish, my dear Kepler, that we could have a good laugh together at the extraordinary stupidity of the mob. What do you think of the foremost philosophers of this University? In spite of my oft-repeated efforts and invitations, they have refused, with the obstinacy of a glutted adder, to look at the planets or Moon or my telescope. by discount phentermine

Posted by: phentermine at April 21, 2005 04:14 PM

pms remedy. pms relief. pms relief

Posted by: pms relief at May 13, 2005 07:28 AM

pms remedy. pms relief. pms relief

Posted by: pms relief at May 29, 2005 11:24 AM

A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on.

Posted by: john at May 29, 2005 09:20 PM

Be nice to people on your way up because you meet them on your way down.

Posted by: paul at May 30, 2005 01:44 AM

webcam chats and gay webcam || webcam xxx and webcam pictures || chat webcam and girls webcam || bahamas webcam and nude webcams || kostenlose sexcams and erotic webcams || xxx chat and my webcam || webcam shots and webcam hack || webcam movies and adult webcam chat || webcam bahamas and free adult cams || florida webcam and adult chat free || logitech webcams and xxx web cams || maine webcams and private cams || notebook webcam and live xxx video || adult cam and xxx chat || webcam girls and xxx cam free || beach webcams and free live webcam || webcam boobs and wireless webcam || webcam sex and teen webcams || girls webcams and free webcam software || sexy webcams and live sex video || yahoo webcam and webcam free || amateur webcams and free webcam sites || sexcams videosexchat and live video cams || streaming webcam and webcam nude || webcam xxx and webcam pictures || jamaica webcam and personal webcams || webcam boobs and wireless webcam || college webcam and free sex chats || webcams free and streaming webcams || cam adult and live teen webcams || tampa webcam and chat adult || beach webcams and free live webcam || webcam communities and free nude chat || nude webcam and web cam chat || girls webcams and free webcam software || webcam girl and free webcam chat || webcam chatrooms and live nude webcams || webcam pictures and bahamas webcam || bahama webcams and girls on webcams || satellite webcam and private web cams || webcam reviews and live video || chats adult and teenchat teen chat || streaming webcam and webcam nude || webcam swingers and free sex webcam || sex cams and secret friends webcam || newfoundland sexcam and hidden sex cams || private cams and amateur webcams || xxx webcam and miami webcam || sex cams and secret friends webcam || weather webcams and new orleans webcam || webcam camarades and webcam voyeur ||

Posted by: web sexcam and bahamas webcams at May 31, 2005 10:58 AM

male webcam and hidden webcam || webcam girls and xxx cam free || ghost webcams and adult free webcams || webcam now and live video chat || webcam spy and webcam community || sturgis webcams and free teen chats || florida webcam and adult chat free || hawaii webcam and creative webcam || pensacola webcam and webcam adult || teen webcams and teen chats || cam adult and live teen webcams || my webcam and adult video chat || home webcams and webcam communities || maine webcams and private cams || webcams cams and webcam women || live webcams and free teen chat || webcam women and free webcam girls || gay webcam and free adult webcam || remove sexcam and free live video || sex cams and adult web cam || nude webcams and sexcam || adult chats and adult cams || teen chat and teen chat connection || girls webcam and teen chat sites || chat adult and florida webcams || webcam directory and webcam florida || weather webcams and new orleans webcam || sexcam virus and aaa sex chat || adult webcams and xxx cam girls || wet sexcam and live adult cams || preteen webcam and free webcam pics || miami webcam and web cam sites || sexcams free and teen girl webcams || private cam and xxx cams || webcam voyeur and adult cam || personal webcams and adult sex chat || webcam xxx and webcam pictures || sexcams and submitted webcam pics || amature sexcams and free private webcams || webcam teens and webcam software || filipino sexcam and logitech webcams || pensacola webcam and webcam adult || chat teen and sturgis webcam || wireless webcam and sex chat room || remove sexcam and free live video || dutch sexcam and free teen webcam || webcam movies and adult webcam chat || photo webcam and logitech webcam || sexcams free and teen girl webcams || webcam capture and amateur webcam || sexcam and xxx cam ||

Posted by: airport webcams and free xxx cams at May 31, 2005 05:27 PM

webcam florida and live adult chat || sex webcam and xxx webcams || chats adult and teenchat teen chat || webcam sex and teen webcams || my webcam and adult video chat || webcams and xxx video cams || world webcams and adult chats || webcam teen and live webcam || webcam xxx and webcam pictures || webcam directory and webcam florida || webcams adult and key west webcam || webcam girl and free webcam chat || sexcam portals and fort lauderdale webcam || halifax webcams and florida webcam || satellite webcam and private web cams || webcam show and free gay webcam || webcam pictures and bahamas webcam || webcam naked and chatrooms adult chat || sexy webcam and gay webcams || free webcams and xxx ewb cams || private webcams and adult free chat || pensacola webcam and webcam adult || hidden sexcams and webcam boys || webcam naked and chatrooms adult chat || miami webcam and web cam sites || webcams girls and daytona beach webcam || adult chats and adult cams || weather webcams and new orleans webcam || sexcam shows and maine webcams || webcam amateur and sex webcam || wet sexcam and live adult cams || girl webcam and free sexcams || girls webcams and free webcam software || webcam show and free gay webcam || adult chats and adult cams || webcam pics and free xxx chat || free sexcam and free teen webcams || webcam photos and free cam girls || nude webcams and sexcam || webcam women and free webcam girls || world webcams and adult chats || hot webcam and home webcam || free webcams and xxx ewb cams || male webcam and hidden webcam || adult webcams and webcams voyeur || amature webcams and teen webcam chat || free webcams and xxx ewb cams || home webcams and webcam communities || webcams girls and daytona beach webcam || chat sex and adult chat room || girls webcams and free webcam software ||

Posted by: webcam drivers and free webcam sex at May 31, 2005 10:00 PM

match makers || singles resorts || dating help || friendly matchmaking || matchmaking serviecs || single greeks || hk match || waterproof matches || radioactive dating || dating || australia matchmaking ||

Posted by: incense matches at June 3, 2005 06:14 AM

sex dating || cd singles || singles sites || intimate dating || match || spanking match || exact match || japanese dating || match strike || price match || anime matchmaking ||

Posted by: dating profiles at June 4, 2005 08:50 AM

singles vacations || military singles || lit match || catholic matchmaking || matchmaking festival || mtg singles || dating websites || single mother || single girl || single amputee || safety matches ||

Posted by: arizona singles at June 4, 2005 08:50 AM

matchmaking serviecs || matchmaking || matchmaking service || single nurses || millionaire match || dating services || pagan dating || wedding matches || bisexual matchmaking || dating sims || discreet dating ||

Posted by: thai dating at June 5, 2005 12:53 PM

ts matchmaking || jewish dating || professional singles || table match || colour match || marriage matchmaking || asian matchmaking || love matches || amateur match || club single || single chat ||

Posted by: utah singles at June 5, 2005 12:53 PM

Hi_please_visit_http://www.soma-med.com

Posted by: soma at June 7, 2005 07:20 PM

Hi_please_visit_http://www.fioricet-med.com

Posted by: fioricet at June 10, 2005 02:01 AM

Hi_please_visit_http://www.consolidatedebtsfast.com

Posted by: debt consolidation at June 11, 2005 05:54 AM

Women might be able to fake orgasms. But men can fake a whole relationship.

Posted by: debt consolidation at June 12, 2005 03:00 AM

Hi_please_visit_http://www.debtconsolidationbureau.com

Posted by: debt consolidation at June 12, 2005 04:10 AM

I can write better than anybody who can write faster, and I can write faster than anybody who can write better.

Posted by: debt consolidation at June 12, 2005 11:13 PM

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Posted by: debt consolidation at June 13, 2005 04:27 AM

Hi_please_visit_http://www.myfioricet.com

Posted by: fioricet at June 15, 2005 06:49 AM

Hi_please_visit_http://www.fioricet-med.com

Posted by: fioricet at June 16, 2005 03:09 PM

Hi_please_visit_http://ovantra.usa-rx-pharmacy.com

Posted by: ovantra at June 17, 2005 12:17 PM

Be nice to people on your way up because you meet them on your way down.

Posted by: hgh spray at June 18, 2005 10:30 PM

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Posted by: debt consolidation at June 20, 2005 12:22 PM

I can write better than anybody who can write faster, and I can write faster than anybody who can write better.

Posted by: hgh at June 21, 2005 12:57 PM

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Posted by: hgh spray at June 21, 2005 07:49 PM

http://www.buy-fioricet-pills.com

Posted by: fioricet at June 29, 2005 02:40 PM

http://www.cheapestsoma.biz

Posted by: soma at June 29, 2005 05:06 PM

http://www.cheapestfioricet.biz

Posted by: fioricet at June 29, 2005 07:31 PM

http://www.fioricetprices.com

Posted by: fioricet at June 30, 2005 05:22 PM

http://www.somaprices.com

Posted by: soma at July 1, 2005 01:09 PM

count low pregnancy sperm sperm count marijuana http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/causes_of_low_sperm_count.html increase sperm quantity marijuana sperm count http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/improving_sperm_count.html and .... count increase low sperm sperm count procedure http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/smoking_and_sperm_count.html count in low man sperm sperm count testing http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/abnormal_sperm_count.html count kit sperm low sperm count pregnancy http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/conceiving_with_low_sperm_count.html .Thanks.

Posted by: count kit sperm at July 1, 2005 02:14 PM

what causes low sperm count average male sperm count http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/home_sperm_count_test.html cell count phone sperm increase sperm volume http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/vitamin_to_increase_sperm_count.html and .... increase sperm count count increase male sperm http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/foods_that_increase_sperm_count.html sperm count analysis raise sperm count http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/low_sperm_count_causes.html zero sperm count count pregnancy sperm http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/count_male_sperm.html .Thanks.

Posted by: lower sperm count at July 1, 2005 02:36 PM

low sperm count treatment count dew mountain sperm http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/count_iui_sperm.html sperm count tests increase sperm production http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/laptop_sperm_count.html and .... sperm count pregnancy sperm count procedure http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/count_fertility_sperm.html sperm count procedure improving low sperm count http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/count_male_sperm.html count in low man sperm count infertility low sperm http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/low_sperm_count_causes.html .Thanks.

Posted by: yellow 5 sperm count at July 1, 2005 02:55 PM

sperm count alcohol sperm count marijuana http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/increase_sperm_amount.html abnormal sperm count count help low sperm http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/what_lower_sperm_count.html and .... count procedure sperm increase amount of sperm http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/improving_sperm_count.html count kit sperm increased sperm count http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/increase_sperm_quality.html increase naturally sperm increase load sperm http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/count_pregnancy_sperm.html .Thanks.

Posted by: increase load sperm at July 1, 2005 03:14 PM

yellow 5 sperm count how to increase sperm count http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/count_raising_sperm.html zero sperm count mountain dew sperm count http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/increase_sperm.html and .... marijuana sperm count count pregnancy sperm http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/improving_low_sperm_count.html low sperm count pregnancy sperm count alcohol http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/count_higher_sperm.html count help low sperm count raising sperm http://777.12345.koreaip.net/sperm/count_low_pregnancy_sperm.html .Thanks.

Posted by: home sperm count test at July 1, 2005 03:31 PM

http://www.cheapestpropecia.biz

Posted by: propecia at July 1, 2005 04:58 PM

http://www.propeciaprices.com

Posted by: propecia at July 2, 2005 12:39 AM

http://www.buy-soma-pills.com

Posted by: soma at July 2, 2005 09:14 PM

ways to increase sperm count boost sperm count http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/count_low_male_sperm.html count decrease sperm sperm count fertility http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/smoking_sperm_count.html and .... sperm count and fertility count kit sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/healthy_sperm_count.html improving sperm count sperm count average http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/count_sperm_testing.html low sperm count causes count increase naturally sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/sperm_count_decline.html .Thanks.

Posted by: causes of low sperm count at July 3, 2005 12:30 AM

improving sperm count increase naturally sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/boost_count_sperm.html count low male sperm increase quantity sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/count_procedure_sperm.html and .... sperm count results count low male sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/iui_sperm_count.html count low reason sperm count low sign sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/count_sperm_zero.html how to increase sperm volume increase sperm amount http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/increase_sperm.html .Thanks.

Posted by: sperm count test at July 3, 2005 01:21 AM

male infertility low sperm count increase your sperm count http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/how_to_improve_sperm_count.html sperm count marijuana ways to increase sperm count http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/what_is_a_normal_sperm_count.html and .... count increase naturally sperm cell count phone sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/raising_sperm_count.html low sperm count causes count dew mountain sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/higher_sperm_count.html smoking and sperm count count dew mountain sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/count_raising_sperm.html .Thanks.

Posted by: increase quantity sperm at July 3, 2005 02:11 AM

iui low sperm count masturbation and sperm count http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/post_vasectomy_sperm_count.html sperm count results masturbation sperm count http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/foods_to_increase_sperm_count.html and .... how to increase sperm volume low sperm count causes http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/count_high_sperm.html count low remedy sperm count low reason sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/foods_that_increase_sperm_count.html count improve sperm increase sperm amount http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/normal_sperm_count.html .Thanks.

Posted by: alcohol sperm count at July 3, 2005 03:09 AM

count iui sperm infertility sperm count http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/conceiving_with_low_sperm_count.html how to increase sperm count zero sperm count http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/sperm_count_kit.html and .... count no sperm boost count sperm http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/low_sperm_count_remedies.html iui sperm count sperm increase http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/what_is_a_normal_sperm_count.html how to increase sperm raising sperm count http://kakmenyazaebali.dnip.net/sperm/causes_of_low_sperm_count.html .Thanks.

Posted by: raising sperm count at July 3, 2005 04:07 AM

cheap phentermine The routine of custom tends to deaden even scientific inquiry; it stands in the way of discovery and of the active scientific worker. For discovery and inquiry are synonymous as an occupation. Science is a pursuit, not a coming into possession of the immutable; new theories as points of view are more prized than discoveries that quantitatively increase the store on hand.

Posted by: cheap phentermine at July 4, 2005 01:58 PM

http://www.lainarkameds.biz

Posted by: fioricet at July 7, 2005 08:52 AM

http://www.thesomapill.com

Posted by: carisoprodol at July 7, 2005 05:37 PM

http://www.myfioricet.com

Posted by: fioricet at July 8, 2005 06:14 AM

Its great site!Thank you!

Posted by: mature granny old at July 8, 2005 10:47 PM

http://www.propeciamed.com

Posted by: propecia at July 8, 2005 11:54 PM

Sometimes even to live is an act of courage.

Posted by: erectile dysfunction at July 9, 2005 12:26 PM

http://zocor.usa-rx-pharmacy.com

Posted by: zocor at July 9, 2005 01:27 PM

http://www.fioricet-med.com

Posted by: fioricet at July 9, 2005 05:20 PM

http://www.soma-med.com

Posted by: soma at July 10, 2005 01:34 PM

cheap phentermine If the question is asked, what are the most intelligent and all-round-capable things on earth, the answer is obvious: human beings. Everyone knows this, except certain religious people. A person is certainly a believer in some religion if he thinks, for example, that there are on earth millions of invisible and immortal nonhuman beings which are far more intelligent and capable than we are. But that is exactly what sociobiologists do think, about genes. Sociobiology, then, is a religion: one which has genes as its gods.

Posted by: cheap phentermine at July 10, 2005 08:07 PM

i'm lovin it :P

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 13, 2005 07:25 PM

wow this is incredible

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 14, 2005 04:05 AM

i'm lovin it :P

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 14, 2005 09:30 AM

nice blog man

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 14, 2005 09:55 PM

wow this is incredible

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 15, 2005 02:07 AM

wow this is incredible

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 15, 2005 03:24 PM

i'm lovin it :P

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 15, 2005 03:46 PM

http://acyclovir.pillspalace.com

Posted by: acyclovir at July 15, 2005 11:37 PM

wow this is incredible

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 16, 2005 08:43 AM

You are the best!

Posted by: mature sex pics at July 16, 2005 12:07 PM

http://albenza.pillspalace.com

Posted by: albenza at July 16, 2005 02:35 PM

nice blog man

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 16, 2005 03:59 PM

i'm lovin it :P

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 16, 2005 04:41 PM

http://aciphex.pillspalace.com

Posted by: aciphex at July 16, 2005 06:15 PM

wow this is incredible

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 16, 2005 09:54 PM

http://cyclobenzaprine.pillspalace.com

Posted by: cyclobenzaprine at July 18, 2005 04:16 AM

http://ultracet.pillspalace.com

Posted by: ultracet at July 21, 2005 03:14 AM

Thanks for comment Mark

Posted by: oreck vacuums at July 23, 2005 02:13 PM

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Posted by: human growth hormone at July 28, 2005 05:54 PM

Fleshlight is an artificial vagina sex toy for men. It is shaped like a flashlight with an opening into which the penis is inserted to simulate penetration or fellatio.

Posted by: fleshlight at July 28, 2005 06:21 PM

I was born inteligent but education ruined me....

Posted by: debt consolidation at July 28, 2005 09:24 PM

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Posted by: human growth hormone at July 29, 2005 08:46 PM

Fleshlight is an artificial vagina sex toy for men. It is shaped like a flashlight with an opening into which the penis is inserted to simulate penetration or fellatio.

Posted by: fleshlight at July 29, 2005 08:53 PM

Post a comment

Name:

Email Address:

URL:

Remember personal info?

Comments: