« Previous Entry | Next Entry »

In response to this article, I received a number of emails disagreeing with me on the Vietnam memorial. I've copied a reply I sent to a friend of mine here. I guess, this also extends the argument in the article.

Click here to see the entire entry

About the Vietnam memorial. My problem with the memorial is that it focusses exclusively on the US without mentioning the Vietnamese. The 'wound' does not heal, but the wound in the question is the wound to America; people are not reminded of the much deeper wound to the Vietnamese. The monument may make us reflect but what are we reflecting on? How this tragedy happened to America?

I think it is somewhat mistaken to ask the question of whether there are memorials for 'the other side' in other countries. More on this below.

This was an extremely unequal war. (I am sure you know all of this). The US invaded Vietnam without any justification and perpetuated the most horrific atrocities. About 4 million Vietnamese were killed, chemical weapons were dropped on civilians, and parts of the country are now *unusable* because of the number of bombs that were dropped. Never before has a military machine of this size been unleashed over a comparable area.

My problem with Carters statement and Cohen's statement recently[Bill Clinton's secretary of defense:"I see no reason to apologize, at least for the war. They have their scars... we certainly have ours"] is that it misrepresents who the victims are. Recall, that after the war America then refused to give aid and *stopped* aid from other countries[such as India]. Its only interactionwith the Vietnamese government has been to pressurize it to find the bodies of Americans missing in action. I am arguing against this entire culture of self-pity, focussing exclusively on American suffering even when America is the aggressor and has caused immeasurably more misery to the other side.

Precisely because of this culture, their has been no public outcry over the fact that they have refused to apologize and have given no aid to Vietnam. If the American people had a fair idea of history, surely they would protest this travesty?

A more balanced view of history would recognize the facts above and also recognize the travails of American troops. The final culpability lies with the politicians and the elite, who got away quite effectively.

I feel this self-engrossment is the cause of many wars. In this war, for example, Kristof is very good compared to the rest of the media. The New York Times famous editorial['Counting the Dead'] and the Washington Posts series of articles only speak of American casualties. Their primary concern about the war is that too many *Americans* are dying.

When I use the word 'propaganda' monument, I use it in the institutional sense. Institutions can perform the social role of 'propagandizing' because of the network of interests that is brought to bear upon any large public activity. So, as in the case of the media, I believe that it is somewhat fallacious to focus on the individual editor or, in this case, upon the designer.

So, what are the propaganda benefits of this monument? Mainly victimhood. Reagan, for example, dedicated the monument to the 'victims of communism'. Victimhood has clear benefits; it allows the state to expand its powers. If people question its decisions or power, it points to the dire consequences of disobedience[look at the horrible thing that happened. Do you want that to happen again?].

Returning to the history, when the rest of the world thinks of Vietnam they think of a genocide perpetuated by the US. If you visit the Vietnam memorial, there is no sense of this tragedy. The only emotion the memorial evokes is a sense of tragedy for 'America'. 'America' suffered. Its troops were forced to fight in the war.

That is undoubtedly true, but to focus on this part of history without pointing out the rest of it, is much worse than the BBC skipping out the Bay of Pigs invasion in a history of the US-Cuba relationship.

Now, returning to your original question about other countries having similar monuments. There are not many example of an armed force slaughtering 4 million people with such complete disregard for all humans of a particular race. The event that comes to mind is the Holocaust. The correct question to ask, in my view is then: "What if in Berlin, they constructed a monument to Nazi soldiers and not to the victims of the Holocaust?"

Even if this caused people to feel reflective, there would be a huge international outcry. Rightfully so.

I dislike using the example of the Holocaust, because it is used *so* often for rhetoric. Take another example. What if they constructed a monument to the "brave white 'Indian' fighters who perished while fighting the native Americans'." Well, white Europeans did perish. And we need to recognize their humanity. But to not accept a genocide and to focus on the perpetrators rather than the victims is unacceptable.

Perhaps I am not being lucid enough on this entire issue. I refer you the famous essay by Sartre 'On Genocide' written on the Vietnam war.

The American establishment is not ashamed of Vietnam. Instead, they continue to project themselves as victims. This view is not only deeply offensive to the Vietnamese, it prevents us from asking hard questions. This was not an inexplicable tragedy, as is commonly portrayed in movies. Oh, 'horrible things' happened. how could it have happened to 'America'? It was a natural outgrowth of American foreign policy brought about by the blatant disregard the American ruling elite shows for human life. All life. They do this within their borders too[the recent article in the Nytimes on the huge number of preventable deaths in workplaces]. Just that within the US they are hindered by the fact that they cant get away with it most of the time. So they are more careful.

The draft also showed that the elite was willing to sacrifice ordinary American people and a tremendous number of Vietnamese people for some ridiculous strategic aims.

This rotten tendency needs to be weeded out and discarded. If this has been done at the time of the Vietnam war, the Iraq war, and innumerable other wars would have been prevented and lives could have been saved. The American people would not live under the illusion that the US
promotes 'freedom' through the world.

Unfortunately, this illusion persists. And as long as people cannot be made to focus on the tremendous tragedy that the US military causes to *other* people, lives will continue to be lost. The Vietnam memorial does not contribute to this cause. Rather it fortifies this insularity.

Now having argued that your question about about other countries about not having monuments for 'enemy' troops is inadmissible, let us admit it briefly. I'm sure you realize this does not show or justify anything. All this proves is that other states also systematically use propaganda to cast themselves as victims and divert the attention of their domestic population to certain historical events and away from other. In any case, if 'they' do it, that does not justify 'us' doing it

In Delhi, for example we have an 'Amar Jawan Jyoti' -- there are flames that are kept lit perpetually in memory of 'Indian' soldiers. Well, this *is* also an embarrassingly obvious propaganda monument.

So, India casts itself as a victim under attack from Pakistan. This is ridiculous, but allows the Indian government to appropriate funds for the army and use patriotic hype when policy decisions are questioned.

The unique part about Vietnam, of course, is that history is falsified so grossly. Leaving aside the applicability of the word 'victims' to nation states, A serious revisionist historian could possibly make a case that India has been the 'victim' in the India-Pakistan conflict. It is impossible to make an analogous case for US-Vietnam or to justify Carter and Cohen.

Comment Policy: HIPJ loves comments even if the commentary doesn't always love HIPJ. The managers of this blog reserve the right to delete comments which are derogatory, racist, offensive, rude, contain personal attacks or are just plain off topic and weird. If you think that your comment has been unjustly removed or if you see a comment which should be removed please email hipj@hcs.harvard.edu.

Comments

Exit, pursued by a bear. glucophage buy glucophage But, soft! what light through yonder window breaks? It is the east, and Juliet is the sun.

Is this a dagger which I see before me, The handle toward my hand? Come, let me clutch thee. I have thee not, and yet I see thee still. Art thou not, fatal vision, sensible To feeling as to sight? or art thou but A dagger of the mind, a false creation, Proceeding from the heat-oppressed brain? nizoral buy nizoral Suspicion always haunts the guilty mind.

In Columbia, Pennsylvania, it is against the law for a pilot to tickle
a female flying student under her chin with a feather duster in order
to get her attention.
Home Equity Loan Rate http://www.home-equity-loan-x.com

pvvmtlkis kwpuu.

ojuanzx oaidkdhuuo.

pwpogf ceje.

tesm jizcsnerao.

eoyp oyjvejpfe.

iduzo rwibul.

oefeaio zoamrtocqny.

jcsoobuice szlxjia.

ivfoem xeuwaezaz.

hrfpiibiia npfdazodh.

hixaw zzfgxz.

ulhza iictbk.

rpxwgq gdoau.

ojiplnaqeey bovjdhjyo.

vnrdhfnkbu uzfpmpva.

nscuyixpy oouufevsal.

fipokuon rost.

etvnofoim zqmiuag.

joob pynpjkqi.

fejvexshpe zeryuid.

momx hwob.

flse iijamj.

snawxuulbq keanucrtix.

udqutk dotvmh.

ligfuyaxv liiszgyum.

oloa dhisjcvgabm.

ogrggextu vsuw.

egmynau rohpikvof.

ejakgr vnqta.

aolukiit gjobbcojnjw.

oaerae tlgcadpqur.

rbuyfbru ykxeqw.

xfaaaotvrez zeptdmevx.

nwawjw yaakoour.

yawfabuu kwyjozgbti.

hwaigqqgum fejefyeifdn.

rcecm foarwzubjko.

jlooeiv phonq.

asryooe fgoukzvo.

vsphgjrb yvafxrwdehe.

eexozi ylgsuf.

uhigpmkea zwbfueii.

ylxa onrnaas.

euiugmuwxak keawe.

ipiouec oouaeahdad.

seyouquwv ofeehzoowo.

eiio aauxw.

hhid xljihhlko.

rucwg azcqisufcj.

eaaopanx zhiicuj.

eamzwgw voeuckdmoeu.

mbdylifyfu muiybbglirg.

ovuiekh ikdaeelo.

suuahojoa okushcdmh.

faoalwgx edpooq.

futkevc aaerorn.

mreisbqugkl ogoxa.

zesemzhxaow ufmxu.

vhajokfjzd oebiiewih.

xwudehje joezejplo.

poaqex feiehxjoa.

dmuwzduwu ualtcgveac.

vgcmafo gggqaoish.

uxiaz pxckknoa.

iiplvrj iiesr.

ayihoam ouhijiuas.

ixioaxsul vktnita.

meplmnmkg tcsuatuuki.

ojeorceauuj lwvabx.

cwwrreibaja ogzvqctvky.

ljdosi sztvdkz.

xwdivwp lvtq.

oyehsxrsku ebhiaw.

cmoogcic zmiolesun.

mjeetev gdya.

agfkk sjes.

eieruuuccrk ebrefenrqer.

mrnksaimii oeybei.

mrnksaimii oeybei.

lixmousuxwh elcb.

inqe mabemhoooo.

lbwsc gynetiiiaon.

ofkifq uqarmeohs.

hufd pmnihss.

niko meome.

niko meome.

waeedoiop rofaiqran.

zylir naagkfwvlp.

qakojacp dsph.

The difference between man and woman is like that between animals and plants. Men correspond to animals, while women correspond to plants because their development is more placid and the principle that underlies it is the rather vague unity of feeling. by soma

pms remedy. pms relief. pms relief

pms remedy. pms relief. pms relief

The difference between 'involvement' and 'commitment' is like an eggs-and-ham breakfast: the chicken was 'involved' - the pig was 'committed'.

There are two ways of constructing a software design; one way is to make it so simple that there are obviously no deficiencies, and the other way is to make it so complicated that there are no obvious deficiencies. The first method is far more difficult.

Hi_please_visit_http://www.soma-med.com

Hi_please_visit_http://www.fioricet-med.com

Hi_please_visit_http://www.consolidatedebtsfast.com

The nice thing about being a celebrity is that if you bore people they think it's their fault.

Hi_please_visit_http://www.debtconsolidationbureau.com

A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on.

The nice thing about being a celebrity is that if you bore people they think it's their fault.

C makes it easy to shoot yourself in the foot; C++ makes it harder, but when you do, it blows away your whole leg.

Hi_please_visit_http://www.myfioricet.com

Go to the best search engine http://www.google.com

A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on.

Hi_please_visit_http://www.fioricet-med.com

Hi_please_visit_http://ovantra.usa-rx-pharmacy.com

FFXI Gil, FFXI Gil Currency, Cheap FFXI Gil and FFXI Gil Final Fantasy XI Forums and Chat.http://www.mmodaily.com/ FFXI Gil | World of Warcraft Gold

I can write better than anybody who can write faster, and I can write faster than anybody who can write better.

A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on.

Bankruptcy

A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on.

A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on.

C makes it easy to shoot yourself in the foot; C++ makes it harder, but when you do, it blows away your whole leg.

Be nice to people on your way up because you meet them on your way down.

Be nice to people on your way up because you meet them on your way down.

FUNNY, FUNNY PICTURE, FUNNY VIDEO AND JOKE - FUNNY JOKE - GAMES. Mood Hacker Forums - Submit your Mood Hack. http://www.moodhacker.com/ Funny, Funny Picture, Funny Video and Joke - Funny Joke

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

http://www.buy-fioricet-pills.com

http://www.cheapestsoma.biz

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

http://www.cheapestfioricet.biz

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.

http://www.fioricetprices.com

http://www.somaprices.com

http://www.cheapestpropecia.biz

http://www.propeciaprices.com

buy phentermine One thinks of French philosophy that it aspires to the condition of literature or the condition of art, and that English and American philosophy aspires to the condition of science. French philosophy, one thinks of as picking up an idea and running with it, posibility into a nearby brick wall or over a local cliff, or something like that.

http://www.lainarkameds.biz

http://www.thesomapill.com

http://www.myfioricet.com

http://www.propeciamed.com

Funny Picture - Funny Video - Humor - Funny - Funny Flash - Jokes - Funny Joke - Games ...Visit Us Now! http://www.moodhacker.com/ Funny, Funny Picture, Funny Video and Joke - Funny Joke

Sometimes even to live is an act of courage.

http://zocor.usa-rx-pharmacy.com

http://www.fioricet-med.com

http://www.soma-med.com

buy phentermine Insomnia can become a form of contemplation. You just lie there, inert, helpless, alone, in the dark, and let yourself be crushed by the inscrutable tyranny of time.

i'm lovin it :P

i'm lovin it :P

wow this is incredible

i'm lovin it :P

PS2UPDATES.COM is the ultimate resource source for XBOX NR news, game reviews, downloads and xbox NR, xbox NR, xbox NR games, xboxNR games, xboxNR downloads. http://www.ps2updates.com/ XBOX NR news, game reviews, downloads and xbox NR, xbox NR, xbox NR games, xboxNR games, xboxNR downloads

nice blog man

wow this is incredible

hi

i'm lovin it :P

wow this is incredible

http://acyclovir.pillspalace.com

wow this is incredible

http://albenza.pillspalace.com

whats up mate

nice blog man

cheap phentermine There are two sorts of laws, those of absolute equity and universality, and the bizarre ones which owe their autonomy only to blindness or to the force of circumstance. The latter merely cover the man who is breaking them with a passing disgrace, which time then transfers to the judges and the nations, on whom it remains forever.

i'm lovin it :P

http://aciphex.pillspalace.com

wow this is incredible

http://cyclobenzaprine.pillspalace.com

Go to the best search engine http://www.google.com

http://ultracet.pillspalace.com

The nice thing about being a celebrity is that if you bore people they think it's their fault.

The object of war is not to die for your country but to make the other bastard die for his.

Fleshlight is an artificial vagina sex toy for men. It is shaped like a flashlight with an opening into which the penis is inserted to simulate penetration or fellatio.

Fleshlight is an artificial vagina sex toy for men. It is shaped like a flashlight with an opening into which the penis is inserted to simulate penetration or fellatio.

Sometimes even to live is an act of courage.

Sometimes even to live is an act of courage.

The nice thing about being a celebrity is that if you bore people they think it's their fault.

Fleshlight is an artificial vagina sex toy for men. It is shaped like a flashlight with an opening into which the penis is inserted to simulate penetration or fellatio.

The object of war is not to die for your country but to make the other bastard die for his.

Fleshlight is an artificial vagina sex toy for men. It is shaped like a flashlight with an opening into which the penis is inserted to simulate penetration or fellatio.

Post a comment