Type “the war on science” into Google. Hit enter. You’ve just received 1,320,000,000 results in 0.28 seconds and, unsurprisingly, “The Republican War on Science” is the top result. It’s a clichéd narrative, not to imply that it’s undeserved. But scroll down to the fifth entry and you’ll find, “The Canadian War on Science”. Canadians? Canada is typically regarded as a left-leaning nation, when measured against the American political spectrum. And left leaning parties are often viewed as embracing scientific discovery and research-based policies, right?
For the sake of full disclosure, in addition to being a Harvard scientist, I’m an overly-apologetic, maple syrup swilling, citizen of America’s hat. Emulating our southern neighbors, Canada’s conservative government is shamefully guilty of waging their own war on science. Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s government is busy attempting to greenwash oil-covered wetlands, while simultaneously gutting funding for water quality monitoring , rendering impotent the national census, and prioritizing federal funding to favor research with direct industrial application. Shameful to be sure, but this is not the war with which we concern ourselves here. In Canada, as in much of the US and Europe, science is under a coordinated attack on a second and much ignored front. The aggressors? The far left.
For every young-earth creationist, climate-science denier, and opponent of stem-cell therapy, there is a GMO-protester, homeopathy enthusiast, and vaccine-a-phobe. The key difference being that on the right end of the political spectrum, the enemy is generally perceived to be big government; on the left, it’s big business.
While recent political trends in North America have bred legislation that reflects the irrational arguments of the right, there is an emerging and alarming trend of legally indulging the irrational left. Take for example the Green Party of Canada, whose mailing list I recently subscribed to. For a while, the incoming e-mail bulletins were mostly innocuous. That all changed a few weeks ago when the bulletins began urgently warning me of the dangers of genetically-modified foods, and not simply the dangers that GMOs could pose to the environment. Instead, these warnings urged me to take action against the “potentially serious threat” that GMOs pose to our personal health.
Just to be clear, there has never been a single reputable, peer-reviewed study that has found any link between the consumption of genetically modified foods and adverse health effects. Perhaps as importantly, there is no proposed mechanism that can explain why any such link could exist. The claim that GMOs are unsafe for human consumption is entirely unsupported and is a prime example of thinking informed by unscientific and purely emotional arguments. For a political party to blindly propagate these ideas is irresponsible at best and, at worst, ideologically-motivated alarmism.
Let me emphasize that the Green Party claims to inform its policies with the best possible science. This is the party that claims to have science on its side. This is a party that a disproportionate number of scientists likely voted for. This is the party that I voted for.
I was so taken aback that I was prompted to do something for the very first time: I sent a concerned letter to my politicians. I e-mailed the leader of the Party, Member of Parliament Elizabeth May, and her shadow cabinet member representing agriculture, Kate Storey. Earnestly thinking that there must be some kind of misunderstanding, I politely expressed my concern and asked them to consider the evidence and reconsider their policies towards GMOs. I offered my knowledge and resources to help clarify the finer points of the science and to answer any question they might have. The reply that I received was less than enthusiastic. Instead of considering their own policies, Mrs. Storey asked me to consider initiating “comprehensive, peer reviewed and independent studies of GMO foods”, stressing the importance of “independent studies, free from the conflict of interest which has compromised the validity of the GMO health research.”
In reply, I sent Mrs. Storey links to reviews featuring over 70 studies meeting her requested criteria. All independent. All peer-reviewed. I tried to emphasize that there exists much independent research on this topic and that as the evidence continues to mount, we are more and more certain that there is no link between adverse health effects and the consumption of GMOs.
Ignoring this, Mrs. Storey’s reply insisted that the seed companies had not allowed independent studies (as though companies have the power to limit independent research) and that we scientists “must free [ourselves] from [our] ties to corporate profit” and that if we cannot, then we “will obviously continue to have distrust from the public.”
At this, I attempted to lead Mrs. Storey through some of the literature to demonstrate that there were, in fact, no conflicts of interest present. I tried to describe the process by which reputable journals attempt to eliminate such conflicts of interest. My email went unanswered.
Back to Google. It’s somewhat comforting to know that I’m not the first person to observe the irrational attitude of the far-left towards science and the political framing of GMOs in particular. Others have recently made similar criticisms of Green parties in other nations. Although the British and Canadian “Green Parties” share no official connections, they seem to share the very same anti-scientific beliefs. This begs the question: Is Green the new color of scientific ignorance?
Aside from removing my name from their mailing list and vowing not to vote Green until they clean up their act, what can be done? Let’s consider the appeals: Logos clearly failed and ethos is likely hopeless, leaving pathos as the final option. And perhaps this is the very crux of the issue: Despite their claims, the far-left is championing legislation not because it’s supported by evidence, but instead because it feels right. Otherwise put, the legislation coincides with a worldview built upon emotionally-motivated misinformation. In this sense, the political spectrum appears to be more of a political donut. The far right and left meet on this donut, ironically sharing far more in common than either would like to admit. Both groups are attempting to coopt science to serve ideology. This is a difficult admission for many of us who identify so strongly with environmentalism, sustainability and other parts of the green manifesto.
Perhaps in today’s age of party politics, there can be no party with which a person can identify completely. At the very least, however, scientists and informed citizens should attempt to hold our politicians to a slightly higher standard, calling them out on their indiscretions when appropriate. I urge you to contact your representatives the next time they back legislation contrary to science. At the very least, their responses may expose a deeper truth about their motivations.
Aaron Larsen is a post-doctoral fellow in the Department of Chemistry and Chemical Biology at Harvard University.
123 comments
bej719 says:
Oct 30, 2020
temukan cara Bagaimana Cara Menurunkan Berat Badan Tanpa Berolahraga di website kami
niken ihsan says:
Nov 1, 2020
Keluaran Togel Sydney terpecaya yang bisa jadi pilihan utama kalian.
Jo says:
Nov 5, 2020
GMOs have always been the way. No wonder we’re suffering through this COVID season now. If the governments had invested in this we would all be in a much better place.
Benu2556 says:
Nov 5, 2020
temukan informasi seputar HP android terbaru dan terpecara di website kami
HKPools69 says:
Nov 6, 2020
Halaman HK Pools malam ini paling cepat dan akurat dari sumber situs keluaran angka togel terpercaya.
iruh736 says:
Nov 7, 2020
temukan info tentang Gadget dan Kesehatan pada blog kami
binomo255 says:
Nov 8, 2020
cara bermain binomo untuk pemula merupakan hal menarik yang mungkin sedang dicari oleh banyak orang. Apakah anda adalah salah satunya? Jika iya, simak penjelasan berikut sampai selesai.
vespr577 says:
Nov 8, 2020
info about Garage Design visit our web
VS Chaitanya says:
Nov 9, 2020
An RO water purifier is the best solution to purify water if the TDS levels in your water source is high.
nail wraps says:
Nov 9, 2020
Pretty Nails Company has the best products to give you pretty nails. Unique nail wraps and a large variety of nail polish colors to chose from.
julian says:
Nov 9, 2020
Czytamy!
ikannila99 says:
Nov 10, 2020
ingin punya usaha sampingan ?, mari pahami semua hal tentang ternak ikan nila
hongkongpools22 says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil keluaran welcome to hk pools terbaru hari ini
data sgp 2021 says:
Nov 10, 2020
Data keluaran hk meliputi Data hk 2021 tercepat hari ini
hkpools says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil keluaran hk pools tercepat malam ini hanya di hongkongpools result
Result Singapore says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil keluaran angka Result Sgp
Result togel hongkong says:
Nov 10, 2020
Result Togel hongkong tercepat malam hari ini
Keluaran togel hongkong says:
Nov 10, 2020
Keluaran togel hongkong malam ini tercepat dan terupdate.
Result togel sydney says:
Nov 10, 2020
Result Togel Sydney – Hasil Angka Togel Hari ini
Keluaran togel taiwan says:
Nov 10, 2020
hasil keluaran togel taiwan malam hari ini terepat
Pengeluaran cambodia says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil pengeluaran cambodia hari ini tercepat
Pengeluaran jowopools says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil pengeluaran togel hari ini terlengkap
pengeluaran kuda lari says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil pengeluaran kuda lari tercepat hari ini
Angka pengeluaran togel hari ini says:
Nov 10, 2020
Angka pengeluaran togel hari ini
keluaran sydney says:
Nov 10, 2020
hasil keluaran sydney terupdate
keluaran cambodia says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil keluaran cambodia terpercaya hari ini
pengeluaran sgp 2021 says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil lengkap Data sgp 2021
data hk says:
Nov 10, 2020
Rekap pengeluaran hk 2021 terlengkap hari ini
keluaran hk 2021 says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil keluaran hk 2021 terlengkap terbaru
pengeluaran data togel says:
Nov 10, 2020
Informasi pengeluaran singapore 2021 terlengkap
rekap togel says:
Nov 10, 2020
Hasil rekap togel hari ini
dunia21xx69 says:
Nov 13, 2020
streaming atau download film terbaru dan paling update cinemaindo
web-informasi says:
Nov 16, 2020
baru memulai blog ?. Pamahami yuuk tips dan trik blogging untuk pemula
guadalupe says:
Nov 17, 2020
Standard. Najlepiej przeczytać i wyrobić sobie uwagi
marcellus says:
Nov 17, 2020
No ja istnieję ostatnim zaczęta. A Wy?
guadalupe says:
Nov 17, 2020
Każdy spośród nas zetknął się z faktem, polecam zaznajomienie się z materiałem.
welcome hk pools says:
Nov 17, 2020
thanks for the information. i like this blog.
lk21xx69 says:
Nov 19, 2020
nonton film online lk21 untuk kalian pecinta film semi terbaik dan terbaru
hudarental says:
Nov 19, 2020
berpergian ke Semarang dan butuh kendaraan, percayakan kepada kami rental mobil semarang terbaik
miears says:
Nov 19, 2020
Nadzwyczaj szałowy post, ciekawe teksty polecam wszystkim literaturę
Floor&Decor says:
Nov 20, 2020
find the best Florand Decor for your home
hasilangka says:
Nov 21, 2020
thanks for the information.
hasilnomor says:
Nov 21, 2020
nomor togel hari ini paling lengkap adalah hasilnomor
Sean says:
Nov 22, 2020
Really good article…keep up the good work
Frank says:
Nov 22, 2020
Thanks…I found this article on Google..thank you so much.
Sarah says:
Nov 22, 2020
Good work here…thanks for the interesting topic.
GooBiMedia says:
Nov 22, 2020
GooBiMedia Merupakan Media Informasi Seputar Dunia Dari A-Z
https://outdoorfiend.com/ says:
Nov 23, 2020
The latest products news and information on all things outdoors.
fishing
seo77 says:
Nov 25, 2020
yuuk kita pahimi semua hal tentang jenis search engine
etzydecor77 says:
Nov 26, 2020
etzydecor.com merupakan Konten Situs Web Pemersatu Bangsa,Sarana Hiburan Foto Meme Lucu Terbaru.Gambar Meme Kocak Viral Indonesia, Koleksi Video Meme Ngakak Upin Ipin.
wpload77 says:
Nov 27, 2020
our website is one stop solution for all you need
no no think says:
Nov 27, 2020
i no think!
Data HK 2020 says:
Nov 28, 2020
Please visit my website for daily updated information of Hongkongpools results. Website will be updated daily for the best convenience of our users.
Thank you for sharing.
result togel toto says:
Nov 28, 2020
Data Keluaran Togel Singapura melihat togel tercepat hari ini terpecaya
hasil togel toto says:
Nov 28, 2020
nomor togel hari ini lengkap beserta tabel angka togel hari ini paling lengkap dan akurat!
result angka says:
Nov 28, 2020
semga jackpot sobat ku!
Bos21 says:
Nov 30, 2020
Duniafilm21 Situs nonton film online dan download film semi terbaru dan terlengkap se dunia21.
Bos21 says:
Nov 30, 2020
Duniafilm21 Tempat streaming film online dan download film semi terbaru dan terlengkap se dunia21.
Savefilm21 says:
Nov 30, 2020
Savefilm21 Situs nonton film indonesia online dan download film semi terbaru dan terlengkap se dunia21.
youwatch says:
Nov 30, 2020
Youwatch Situs nonton drama korea subtite indonesia terlengkap dan hemat kuota.
hasiltogel says:
Nov 30, 2020
sangat bermantaat. togel hari ini
resulttercepat says:
Nov 30, 2020
resul tercepat
nomorkeluar says:
Nov 30, 2020
nomor togel today.
cekkeluaranto says:
Nov 30, 2020
cek keluaran togel
hasiltogeltoto says:
Nov 30, 2020
hasil togel toto
welcomtogel@gmail.com says:
Nov 30, 2020
hasil hongkong togel tercepat hari ini
nomorpengeluaran says:
Nov 30, 2020
nomor pengeluaran togel tercepat hari ini
nomorotglejitu says:
Nov 30, 2020
nomor togel jitu hari ini
prediksi hk malam ini says:
Dec 1, 2020
hello how are you all, i am an education teacher living in bali
dealeroli77 says:
Dec 2, 2020
Dealer pelumas pertamina adalah salah satu perusahaan yang bergerak bergerak di bidang Supplier dan Distributor oli pelumas dan grease gemuk untuk industri, mesin kapal, alat berat dan mesin kendaraan.
สยามรวย says:
Dec 2, 2020
หวยมาเลย์ หวยมาเลย์ หวยมาเล หวยมาเลเซีย หรือว่า หวยแม๊กนั่ม (Magnum) เป็นหวยที่ออกโดยชอบด้วยกฏหมายของประเทศมาเลเซีย หรือก็คือถูกต้องตามกฏหมายของประเทศมาเลเซีย หากท่านสนใจที่จะเล่นหวยมาเลย์ siamruay คืออีกหนึ่งทางเลือกที่ดีที่สุด ซึ่งทางเว็บของเราก็จะมีการอัปเดตผลหวยมาเลย์หลังหวยออกทันที!
nanc says:
Dec 2, 2020
Hello
I enjoyed this part, thank you
I saved this page and will come again
Thankful
prediksi hk says:
Dec 3, 2020
Magnificent website. Lots of helpful information here.
I am sending it to some buddies ans additionally sharing in delicious.
And naturally, thank you to your sweat!
Lk21 Semi says:
Dec 3, 2020
Streaming Semi hanya menyajikan film unggulan untuk kalian pencinta film semi
keluaran togel says:
Dec 6, 2020
keluaran togel lengkap
togel Hongkong says:
Dec 6, 2020
info permainan keluaran HK terpercaya.
jalan jalan ke pulau seribu says:
Dec 6, 2020
paket wisata pulau sepa
สยามรวย says:
Dec 7, 2020
Government lottery Government lottery or government lottery Is a kind of lottery in Thailand That Thai people like And known well By purchasing a lottery for the government lottery Will be a lottery purchase Or lotteries from people who sell lotteries There will be a total of 6 numbers, the price is 80 baht, if you win the 1st prize, you will receive a full amount of 6 million baht.
duta film says:
Dec 7, 2020
lk21 semi merupakan tempat nonton film subtitle Indonesia dengan kualitas HD secara gratis. Streaming film box office terbaru dan tempat Download terbaru.
قالب وبلاگ says:
Dec 7, 2020
Hello
I saved this page and will come again
I enjoyed this part, thank you
Thankful
Harry says:
Dec 8, 2020
Very interesting article. I’ve bookmarked this page. Thank you.
hadiah383 says:
Dec 9, 2020
Poker online terpercaya terpecaya untuk jadi pilihan utama kalian
Aman Pathak says:
Dec 10, 2020
Very informative article. Thank you very much for sharing with us.
home shopping says:
Dec 12, 2020
HalloweenBulk
Data Hk says:
Dec 12, 2020
Hasil keluaran hk terlengkap.
simplevpn77 says:
Dec 14, 2020
vpn master mrupakan applikasi terpecaya untuk kalian
Keluaran HK says:
Dec 16, 2020
http://www.karemaski.com adalah situs yang menyediakan Data HK 2020, pengeluaran hk, keluaran hk, result hk terlengkap dan tercepat
Casinoroyal7 says:
Dec 17, 2020
Casinoroyal7 tempat daftar agen slot online terbaik yang mengedepankan sistem fairplay, deposit kilat dan pembayaran withdraw secara penuh yang hanya diberikan oleh agen slot terpercaya di Indonesia.
Khieuware says:
Dec 17, 2020
Thanks for a marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you happen to be a great author. I will remember to bookmark your blog and will often come back at some point. I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great writing, have a nice day!
data sgp says:
Dec 17, 2020
looking for information about the latest and most trusted online lottery only at http://collaboratory.cc/, win big and become the greatest
home shopping says:
Dec 17, 2020
https://www.facebook.com/HalloweenBulk
hasil angka hongkong says:
Dec 18, 2020
thanks for info,nice very nice.
adalah situs yang menyediakan Data HK 2020, pengeluaran hk, keluaran hk
hasilnomor21 says:
Dec 19, 2020
result togel terlengkap semua pasaran tersedia.
Kakakjudi says:
Dec 22, 2020
Daftar Togel Terpercaya dan pasaran terlengkap hanya disini
Anakjd says:
Dec 22, 2020
Poker Online Terpercaya dengan pelayanan 24Jam Terbaik
Gerai4D says:
Dec 22, 2020
Judi Togel Online
Hongkong Pools says:
Dec 22, 2020
Hongkong Pools
galamedia77 says:
Dec 23, 2020
Bambang Sunarwibowo merupakan calon kapolri yang baru
Newspaperadda says:
Dec 24, 2020
Really enjoyed this article.Really thank you!
papatogel69 says:
Dec 24, 2020
keluaran sydney adalah hasil keluaran togel sydney terlengkap dan tercepat
datahk99 says:
Dec 24, 2020
datahk merupakan situs togel hongkong yang menyediakan hasil hasil selama ini yang di keluarkan oleh togel hongkong.
https://www.anakjd88.club/ says:
Dec 25, 2020
What’s up, I’m Lisa. I’m a web developer living in Tokyo. I am a fan of design, arts, and technology. I’m also interested in writing and web development. You can visit my website with a click on the button above.
Klara says:
Dec 26, 2020
Thanks for the marvelous posting! I really enjoyed reading it. David Bowie Collection
David Foster says:
Dec 26, 2020
Thank you. Van Halen Collection
rolet online says:
Dec 28, 2020
I think this site will grow
tvtap per pc says:
Dec 28, 2020
thanks for the information. i like this blog. tvtap per pc
dekorasi77 says:
Dec 29, 2020
rumah kecil dengan dekosrasi indah dan terlihat mewah
สยามรวย says:
Dec 30, 2020
หวยออมสิน หวยออมสิน หรือ สลากออมสิน สลากกินแบ่งออมสิน เป็นหวยของธนาคารออมสิน การแทงหวยออมสิน มีวิธีเล่นเหมือนหวยใต้ดินทั่วไป ซึ่งทางเว็บสยามรวยจะเริ่มเปิดรับแทงหวยล่วงหน้าก่อนวันหวยออกประมาณ 5 วัน และจะปิดรับแทงหวยเวลา 12.30 น. ในวันที่หวยออก ทุกวันที่ 1 และ วันที่ 16 ของทุกเดือน
predator04 says:
Dec 30, 2020
http://www.hcs.harvard.edu/~policylab/2013/07/03/not-so-quiet-on-the-left-ern-front/#comment-292614
predator04 says:
Dec 30, 2020
Visit our website and enjoy with us!
osg777
Multi Karya says:
Jan 1, 2021
CV. Multi Karya Berdikari mulai beroperasi pada 27 Oktober 2005 dan bergerak di bidang pekerjaan pemancangan, erection rangka baja jembatan dan pabrikasi baja, serta sewa crane kalimantan .
Rose B. says:
Jan 2, 2021
Thats way far truth!
kaskuserr says:
Jan 3, 2021
kunjungi websie binomo terbaru 2021. dan login binomo menggunakan akun kalian
http://caddoduckblind.com/ says:
Jan 12, 2021
http://caddoduckblind.com/
sebuah situs togel online terbaik dan terpercaya
کلینیک کاشت مو says:
Jan 14, 2021
Thanks for every other wonderful post
hi have good day
I have a presentation next week
The place else may just anybody get that type of information in such an ideal way of writing ?
Algotech says:
Jan 15, 2021
Algotech adalah perusahaan dan jasa pembuatan website toko online di medan, kami sudah berdiri sejak tahun 2013 dan sudah mempuyai pengalaman lebih dari 50 perusahaan di tangani.
stock photo says:
Jan 15, 2021
are there any photo or hd stock photos free download that are 100% free? Of course there is. In this article we will be told a list of sites to download images or photos without costing a penny forever.
xfilm says:
Jan 16, 2021
free download Girls Losing of Virginity updated everyday
Technezia says:
Jan 20, 2021
Listening to music is now even easier to do, because it can be enjoyed through devices or gadgets such as laptops or smartphones. At present many service providers or music streaming applications that are accessed by streaming, either free or there are also paid. Now, in this discussion, Technezia has selected and recommended some of the best Music Steaming apps for your lyrics. Even lately listening to music streaming has become a trend and music streaming applications are now widely enjoyed.
gamekentang says:
Jan 23, 2021
gamekentang merupakan blog yang dibuat pada pada tahun 2020. Blog ini dibuat bertujuan untuk sharing informasi kepada pembaca tentang Web Informasi Tentang Games, Apps, Tech, Tips dan Tutorial
literature blog says:
Jan 25, 2021
On the Internet, there are many websites that are used as platforms for nerds to satisfy their passion for literature. Librarians recommend 5 special best books review for those of you who prefer to shop for books to buy new clothes because you know books are windows to the world.
JetBlue Telefono says:
Jan 28, 2021
Thanks for the information provided by you it’s really great to help from your side
frontier airlines telefono español says:
Jan 28, 2021
A good blog gives a lot more knowledge about this. I will continue to support your work Thank you